We round off March with a dramatic love story set in the early 1900's, but will it be a winter of discontent or a;
Summer in February
The film is based on the true story of the Newlyn School of artists that flourished at the beginning of the 20th Century, focusing on the fairly wild and bohemian Lamorna Group, which included Alfred Munnings and Laura and Harold Knight. Munnings; an anti-Modernist painter, (now regarded as one of Britain's most sought-after artists, apparently), formed one side of a complex love triangle, along with aspiring artist Florence Carter-Wood and Gilbert Evans, the land agent in charge of the Lamorna Valley estate. It's a moving tale played out against the backdrop of the Cornish coast, in the years leading up to The Great War.
Well, that's what you are lead to believe if you read the DVD cover and various synopses. In reality Summer in February turns out to be a rather bleak story, with a very thin plot, yes that plot is based on the real lives of these artists, but there's no real spark to the story. And akin to a lot of art, there is more than a modicum of pretentiousness about the film, just because an artist is classed as bohemian, gifted and fiery does not make them fascinating, if anything it makes them loathsome, tedious and pretentious. And this is what we find with one of the central characters; A.J. Munnings, although he is played extremely well by Dominic Cooper, who displays perfectly the intense and impulsive characteristics of the artist, his demeanor, attitude and outlook within the piece are tiresome and somewhat banal.
Onto some plus points, Emily Browning is a delight to watch as Florence Carter-Wood, although the full frontal nudity scene was a tad gratuitous in the grandest scheme of things, pretty none-the-less. However, Florence is also a fairly mundane character, with a penchant for the melodramatic. She is torn between Munnings and Gilbert Evans played by Dan Stevens, he of Downton Abbey fame, in a tricky love triangle. Dan Stevens plays the part very well, but he is no different really to the affable character he plays in Downton Abbey and we only highlight him as a plus point, due to the fact that in one scene he does actually make you sit up and watch, but it was only the one scene.
Other positives are the scenery and music, both very important parts of any film, it's just that the Cornish coast is more pleasing to the eye in Summer in February than most of the acting. Also, just because you like period dramas does not mean that all period dramas are good. Highlighted as a "must see" for Downton Abbey fans, Summer in February is a let down. It doesn't have half the appeal of Downton and just because Dan Stevens appears in both, does not make it good.
From a Tuesday Night is Film Night perspective it's a disappointment and therefore a short blog. If you want more opinions check out the Amazon reviews, just wish we had paid more attention to them before clicking on "Add to Basket"!
TNiFN Rating 36%
IMDB Link